Planned

:speech_balloon:

"Decision variables"

Milestones are great – they work kinda like “timestamp variables”

I’d love to have something similar to milestones that work like “boolean variables”

It would be nice to be able to - create a decision variable like “have a big wedding?” or “fully pay for kids college?” - assign certain expenses to be hidden if a decision is true/false, and - toggle the decision with a single click to see its impact on the chart/milestones

21 votes

Tagged as Suggestion

Suggested 04 February 2022 by user Ankush Gupta

Moved into Planned 08 February 2022

  • Sign in to comment and vote. Sign in by email
  • 04 February 2022 Ankush Gupta suggested this task

  • 04 February 2022 Kyle Nolan approved this task

  • 08 February 2022 Kyle Nolan moved this task into Planned

  • avatar

    I’ve also been thinking about this feature, and was about to add something similar. What Ankush describes is probably more flexible and easier to use.

    I was thinking about having expenses optionally depend on Milestones, and add the ability to toggle off and on milestones themselves, which would then automatically turn their dependent expenses off and on.

    But what Ankush describes would allow you to roll-up exactly which expenses depends on a specific decision variable, which could comprise multiple milestones, or parts of many, and other life events. So this approach seems like a better way to go, more all encompassing. Although maybe for visual clarity on the chart you could have Milestones depend on Decision Variables, such that you could hide them.

    e.g. you could have “Get Married” as a decision variable, which would have expenses and milestones associated with it.

    And you could have Decision Variables depend on other decisions variables. e.g. You may want to say “Have a kid” Decision Variable, depends on “Getting Married” == true. and “Adopt a Kid” decision variable, depends on Getting Married == false. And of course each of these decision variables could have numerous different dependent expenses.

    I would also like to see House assets be able to depend on these Decision Variables. e.g. “Have 1-2 kids” makes us choose a specific House asset, vs. no kids, or 3-4 kids.

    Even cash-flow priorities might make use of these Decision Variables.

    28 April 2022
  • avatar

    It’d be helpful if decision variables could depend on other decision variables. Example:

    • Decide to buy land.
    • IF bought land: Decide to build a rental unit
    29 April 2022
  • avatar

    More on this: some decisions depend on having taken other decisions, and some decisions preclude other decisions.

    29 April 2022