Suggestions

:speech_balloon:

Recurring Debt Item - Buy, Borrow, Die strategy

Add support for recurring debt items, or a debt that expands each year by the specified amount. This could be used to model borrowing money to pay expenses. i.e. this debt item would actually replace some portion of expenses.

7 votes

Tagged as Suggestion

Suggested 09 August 2024 by user Shawn S

  • Sign in to comment and vote. Sign in by email
  • 09 August 2024 Shawn S suggested this task

  • avatar

    Thanks- It would be good to have this feature

    09 August 2024
  • 09 August 2024 Kyle Nolan approved this task

  • avatar

    This would also be helpful if it could be modeled as a portfolio LOC, or asset refinance. If modeled as a PAL/PLOC it would be great to show credit available, and model the interest rate as SOFR+ or something similar.

    If asset backed, something like LTV ratios would be helpful.

    19 August 2024
  • avatar

    I would love to have a margin loan as a source of cash flow ProjectionLab could get money from, rather than selling assets. Parameters could include: - Max % of assets borrowed - Interest rate - Expiration date (though a margin loan has no expiration date, I like to use box spreads, which do expire).

    04 January
  • avatar

    +1 to this feature for modeling pledged asset loans.

    If unfamiliar, a brokerage will give you a loan with your investment as collateral. You can spend without realizing a gain by selling, but you pay an interest rate based on SOFR+ as Trent said above.

    Where PL currently fails is modeling this as a debt hits your net worth, which seems to influence your gains. This isn’t accurate, since the whole point of a PAL is to allow your investments to continue to grow, with the bet being that your gains will outstrip the interest over time.

    I like to use PL as a model for deciding when I might want to pay off a PAL, or seeing the impact at least. I need to know how it grows, and what a payoff will do.

    As it stands, I have the PAL modeled as an asset with 0 value, no down payment, and interest accruing. To sell I check my debt line in the chart and hover over a year then add a one time expense. It would be much nicer to set a milestone and just move it around. This would allow me to model repaying the PAL with cash, funding it with whatever account I specify, and not taking a hit to my gains.

    07 February
  • avatar

    Another thought: If a loan had a tick box to “Exclude debt from liquid net worth calculations” (like financed asset does) then I think it would fix the “bug” I’m seeing? Or maybe I don’t quite understand what that tick box does. :)

    07 February