Suggestions

:speech_balloon:

Capital Gains/Income Harvester (leanfire)

This is somewhat similar to the ideas I mentioned on the Roth conversion ladder changemap ticket, and suggests a way to do roth conversions, and tax gain harvesting with the same cashflow priority.

We discussed this a bit on the discord as well. It’s basically a special type of cashflow priority, where the money being spent is on taxes, if any, from the action of taking a step up in basis on a taxable account. (i.e. selling and repurchasing the same assets), or taxes paid to convert tax-deferred money to roth.

Tax gain harvesting is less talked about than tax loss harvesting, but is a powerful strategy for people who’s expenses keep them below the 0% to 15% cap gains breakpoint.

In either case: 1. taxable account and capital gains harvesting, or 2. roth conversions I think it would work like this:

    1. You select an account (taxable or tax-deferred), based on the account type you selected the cashflow priority knows which kind of income you’re harvesting (long-term capital gains, or ordinary income).
    1. you select a threshold up to which you’d like to convert (e.g. up to the 0%-to-15% cap gains threshold, or the 12%-22% ordinary income threshold), or possibly an amount of additional taxes you’d be willing to pay.
    1. If the selected account type is tax-deferred, you’d need to select a Roth destination account for the proceeds. In the taxable account scenario, the funds stay where they are, and receive a step-up in cost basis.

14 votes

Tagged as Suggestion

Suggested 19 April 2022 by user Shawn S

  • Sign in to comment and vote. Sign in by email
  • 19 April 2022 Shawn S suggested this task

  • 19 April 2022 Kyle Nolan approved this task

  • avatar

    This would be useful. I think that it might also be useful to have the option to liquidate principal. For example, you plan to move to Italy where Roth IRA is taxed as normal income so you choose to withdraw all contributions prior to moving and only pay tax on the gains in the future.

    01 October 2024
  • avatar

    Just starting out with Projectionlab but this is important to me. I need to be able to compare Tax Gain Harvesting to Roth Conversion.

    08 December 2024